
The ATO's decision to stop accepting direct credit card payments from 1 July 2027 has stirred plenty of anger. But behind the argument about card fees sits a much more uncomfortable question: 'why are businesses using expensive credit cards to pay their tax bills in the first place?'
Card surcharges disappeared from direct ATO payments on 1 October 2026, and the ATO has extended credit card acceptance until 30 June 2027. Payments through third-party providers will remain possible, although these can carry costs of their own.
Understandably, businesses want flexibility. A slow-paying customer, an unusually large BAS or a seasonal downturn can squeeze even a sound operation. A credit card can sometimes bridge a short gap.
But bridging a gap and building a business around debt are very different things.
GST collected from customers, provisional tax and PAYG withholding from employees are obligations that must be passed on. They should be planned for, not mistaken for money available to keep the lights on.
If every quarterly BAS requires another turn of the credit card, we need to ask whether the real issue is pricing, margins, poor debtor collection, excessive drawings or simply a business that is no longer generating enough cash.
Then there is the curious business model built around credit card points.
Many owners deliberately put large expenses through rewards cards to collect frequent flyer points, flights, upgrades and lounge access. There is nothing wrong with earning rewards on spending that would happen anyway, provided the balance is cleared and the numbers justify the arrangement.
But how often do we actually do the maths?
Consider a hypothetical $20,000 business payment.
For this example, let's assume a card and payment arrangement that earns rewards worth $200 to the business. (of course working out how many 'points' are needed to convert into $1.00 can be difficult on a good day!) A third-party payment provider charges an assumed 2% processing fee, or $400.
Already the transaction costs $200 more than the estimated reward.
Now assume the $20,000 remains outstanding for three months, attracting interest at 20% per annum. Using a simple interest calculation, that adds approximately $1,000.
The combined fees and interest amount to $1,400, against a $200 reward. The business is approximately $1,200 worse off.
That is not a free flight. That is an extraordinarily expensive way to book a seat.
Of course, these figures are illustrative, not universal. Interest rates, processing fees, rewards eligibility and redemption values vary considerably. Some cards exclude government payments from earning points, while others offer reduced rates. Some businesses avoid interest entirely by paying their statement balance in full.
Actual interest also depends on daily balances, repayment timing and the card's interest-free conditions. The example deliberately excludes individual tax consequences, which can also affect the final cost.
For a disciplined business paying no interest and earning rewards worth more than its fees, the arrangement can make financial sense.
But that is precisely why the numbers matter.
Annual card fees, redemption restrictions and the genuine value of points also belong in the calculation. A flight advertised at a high cash price is not necessarily worth that amount to the person redeeming points.
The bigger problem is that credit cards can conceal the true state of a business. Suppliers are paid, the tax bill disappears from the ATO account and everything looks calm. Meanwhile the debt has merely moved to a lender charging a potentially punishing rate.
Business owners deserve practical choices, including realistic ATO payment arrangements and suitable commercial finance when short-term funding is genuinely needed.
But they also deserve clear-eyed advice.
If you could not pay your next BAS without borrowing, ask why now, rather than after another year of interest charges.
Reward points are a bonus, not a business plan. And a credit card should be a payment method, not the foundation holding the business upright.